Book Search:  

 

 
Google full text of our books:

bookjacket

Beyond the Formalist-Realist Divide:
The Role of Politics in Judging
Brian Z. Tamanaha

Paperback | 2009 | $28.95 / £19.95 | ISBN: 9780691142807
264 pp. | 6 x 9
| SHOPPING CART

eBook | ISBN: 9781400831982 |
Our eBook editions are available from these online vendors

Reviews | Table of Contents
Chapter 1[PDF] pdf-icon

Google full text of this book:
 

According to conventional wisdom in American legal culture, the 1870s to 1920s was the age of legal formalism, when judges believed that the law was autonomous and logically ordered, and that they mechanically deduced right answers in cases. In the 1920s and 1930s, the story continues, the legal realists discredited this view by demonstrating that the law is marked by gaps and contradictions, arguing that judges construct legal justifications to support desired outcomes. This often-repeated historical account is virtually taken for granted today, and continues to shape understandings about judging. In this groundbreaking book, esteemed legal theorist Brian Tamanaha thoroughly debunks the formalist-realist divide.

Drawing from extensive research into the writings of judges and scholars, Tamanaha shows how, over the past century and a half, jurists have regularly expressed a balanced view of judging that acknowledges the limitations of law and of judges, yet recognizes that judges can and do render rule-bound decisions. He reveals how the story about the formalist age was an invention of politically motivated critics of the courts, and how it has led to significant misunderstandings about legal realism.

Beyond the Formalist-Realist Divide traces how this false tale has distorted studies of judging by political scientists and debates among legal theorists. Recovering a balanced realism about judging, this book fundamentally rewrites legal history and offers a fresh perspective for theorists, judges, and practitioners of law.

Review:

"Tamanaha has written a provocative challenge to conventional wisdom about the rise of judicial realism. . . . Strongly recommended for scholars and students of law, political science, and history."--Choice

"Beyond the Formalist-Realist Divide is a clearly written and groundbreaking book. Although its focus is historical, its objective--in which it succeeds--is to change the way we think about law today."--Henry Cohen, Federal Lawyer

"Tamanaha's book reflects some striking research into the views of (largely forgotten or neglected) 19th-century law professors and jurists, and the material he has brought to our attention will demand attention from legal historians. . . . [W]e should be grateful to Tamanaha for his provocative historical research, for laying down a vigorous challenge that should be met by historians of ideas and social scientists, and for imparting appropriate intellectual caution and modesty to future writers who might otherwise be prone to casual talk about a 'formalist' age in American legal thought."--Brian Leiter, Legal Theory

"Tamanaha's . . . book will change the way we think about both formalism and realism, about the history of legal scholarship and about the empirical study of judicial decision making."--Edward Rubin, Law and Politics Review

Endorsement:

"Beyond the Formalist-Realist Divide will forever change our understanding of American legal realism and its mythical opponent, legal formalism. Generations of judges, lawyers, and scholars have come to see a false picture that pits radically skeptical realists against naïve or deceptive formalists. Tamanaha's magnificent book will open your eyes and change the way you think about the law. Every lawyer and judge should read this book. Every legal scholar must!"--Lawrence Solum, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign

More Endorsements

Table of Contents:

Acknowledgments ix
CHAPTER 1: Introduction 1
PART ONE: THE LEGAL FORMALISTS
CHAPTER 2: The Myth about Beliefs in the Common Law 13
CHAPTER 3: The Myth about "Mechanical Jurisprudence" 27
CHAPTER 4: The Holes in the Story about Legal Formalism 44
PART TWO: The Legal Realists
CHAPTER 5: Realism before the Legal Realists 67
CHAPTER 6: A Reconstruction of Legal Realism 91
PART THREE: STUDIES OF JUDGING
CHAPTER 7: The Slant in the "Judicial Politics" Field 111
CHAPTER 8: What Quantitative Studies of Judging Have Found 132
PART FOUR: LEGAL THEORY
CHAPTER 9: The Emptiness of "Formalism" in Legal Theory 159
CHAPTER 10: Beyond the Formalist-Realist Divide 181
Afterword 200
Notes 203
Index 251

Subject Areas:

Shopping Cart:

  • For ebooks:

Our eBook editions are available
from these online vendors:

  • Google Play eBook Store
  • Kno eBook Store
  • Many of our ebooks are available through
    library electronic resources including these platforms:

  • Books at JSTOR
  • Ebrary
  • Ebook Library
  • EBSCO Ebooks
  • MyiLibrary
  • Dawsonera (UK)

  • Shopping Cart:

    • For hardcover/paperback orders:

      For hardcover/paperback orders in the United States, Canada, Latin America, Asia, and Australia

      Paperback: $28.95 ISBN: 9780691142807

      For hardcover/paperback orders in Europe, Africa, the Middle East, and India, and Pakistan

      Paperback: £19.95 ISBN: 9780691142807

      Add to shopping cart

      Prices subject to change without notice

      File created: 11/10/2014

    Questions and comments to: webmaster@press.princeton.edu
    Princeton University Press

    New Book E-mails
    New In Print
    PUP Blog
    Videos/Audios
    Princeton APPS
    Sample Chapters
    Subjects
    Series
    Catalogs
    Princeton Legacy Library
    Textbooks
    Media/Reviewers
    Class Use
    Rights/Permissions
    Ordering
    Recent Awards
    Princeton Shorts
    Freshman Reading
    PUP Europe
    About Us
    Contact Us
    Links
    F.A.Q.
    PUP Home


    Bookmark and Share
    Send me emails
    about new books in:
    Law
    Political Science and International Relations
    More Choices