Book Club Pick: The Fire Is upon Us

Book Club Pick: The Fire Is upon Us

By Meagan Levinson

For a three year stretch in my late twenties, I was in a book club with a handful of other people who also worked in publishing. We met once a month in the café at Trident Bookstore in Boston to discuss that month’s pick over dinner and a beer.

We took turns choosing books each month, and the selections varied widely, from literary fiction to pop science to graphic novels. In the first meetings, we all seemed to proceed with a bit of caution, as we were learning how to talk about the books with each other. But by the third meeting, we had hit our stride. It was clear that we had very different taste in books, and very different criteria for what made for a good read, but we listened and respected other’s opinions, and the conversations were animated and lively. Though the books were always the starting point for our evenings, the discussion frequently expanded to broader topics, and we’d only break up the meeting because someone needed to catch a train or a bus. Even then, those of us with a bit more time would linger, continuing to chat as we browsed in the store.

Book clubs can be an incredible space for conversation and connection. They can encourage us to read more widely, to listen more fully, and to engage more deeply with people who have a different perspective.

Each month, Princeton University Press will feature a book that we think is an ideal selection for book clubs. We will offer a set of questions to guide discussions that you might have, and we encourage you to share feedback from your conversations with us via social media. Use hashtag #ReadPUPforBookClub.

This month’s selection is The Fire Is upon Us by Nicholas Buccola. In this book, Buccola tells the unforgettable story of the historic debate at the Cambridge Union between James Baldwin, the leading literary voice of the civil rights movement, and William F. Buckley Jr., a fierce critic of the movement and America’s most influential conservative intellectual. The topic was “the American dream is at the expense of the American Negro,” and no one who has seen the debate can soon forget it. The New York Times Book Review called The Fire Is upon Us “a gripping snapshot of a country riven by injustice yet anxious about radical change.” It is an excellent choice for book clubs that are interested in history, James Baldwin, and race relations in America.

Discussion Questions

The unforgettable account of a debate that continues to illuminate America’s racial divide today, The Fire Is upon Us is an especially compelling selection for reading groups. The questions that follow are meant to enhance your personal understanding or group discussion of this remarkable story of race and the American dream.

  1. Compare and contrast Baldwin and Buckley’s upbringings. How did their environments differ? What values did they share?
  2. Buccola mentions many notable figures, both academic and otherwise, that greatly influenced both men in their twenties. Who were their mentors, and what impact did they have?
  3. Buckley and Baldwin published numerous writings about events that occurred within the Civil Rights Movement. Which piece struck you the most, and why?
  4. Discuss the different strands of Baldwin’s “Down at the Cross”. How did Buckley respond? What were the impacts of religion on their views surrounding race?
  5. Discuss Baldwin and Buckley’s speeches at the Cambridge Union. Were there any moments that Buccola recounts that surprised you? Which points were most convincing?
  6. About Baldwin’s “I picked the cotton” line of reasoning in his speech at Cambridge, Buccola writes, “When Cambridge undergraduate Christie Davies…heard these words, he thought to himself, ‘He’s won.’” (page 257) Do you agree? Why or why not?
  7. In his speech, Buckley says, “I am asking you not to make politics as the crow flies.” (page 273) What does he mean? What does he suggest should be done instead?
  8. How is the debate topic “the American dream is at the expense of the American Negro” still relevant today? Do any of Baldwin and Buckley’s points still apply? Why or why not?
  9. Discuss the public reception of the debate. What were the lasting effects of the debate on American society?
  10. Were you familiar with the Baldwin v. Buckley debate before reading this book? If not, what was most surprising about the event?